Discover the best thrift stores and antique shops in NJ and VT. Get expert thrifting tips and enjoy fun adventures with friends. Perfect for second-hand shopping enthusiasts!
Thrifting offers eco-friendly, budget-friendly, and unique shopping experiences. But did you know how different the experience is in different parts of the country?
In this guide, I’ll share my favorite thrift stores in New Jersey and Vermont, along with tips and stories from my thrifting adventures with friends and family.
(Posts on stacyling.com may contain affiliate links. Click HERE for full disclosure.)
Second-Hand Shopping: Why I Love Thrifting
Thrifting is an eco-friendly and budget-friendly way to find unique items. It’s a fun, sustainable shopping alternative that offers treasures you won’t find in regular stores. Second-hand shopping is a great way to decorate your home on a budget and a fun day out when thrifting with friends. I always learn a lot from my friends when we go and it’s fun to see how we view the value of finds differently.
The Top Thrift Stores and Antique Shops in New Jersey
I love finding vintage or vintage-inspired things that mix with my houseplants and garden decor. Since we don’t have many options available in my area, I visit a variety of shops that sell a range of items from thrift stores, to antique stores and flea markets, as well as shops that sell some vintage reproductions.
Whether you’re looking for vintage clothing, eclectic home decor, or rare collectibles, the Garden State has something for everyone. You just gotta be willing to look for it a little more. From the bustling Market Street Mission Thrift Store in Morristown to the curated selections at The Independent Thrift in Madison, each shop provides a distinct second-hand shopping experience.
Let’s dive into some of the top thrift stores and antique shops near me in New Jersey. Here are some of my favorite thrift store recommendation that you won’t want to miss.
Market Street Mission Thrift Store, Morristown, New Jersey
Located at 25 George Street, the Market Street Mission Thrift Store is a must-visit for anyone interested in second-hand shopping. This thrift store is part of a larger mission to help the local community, with proceeds supporting addiction recovery programs.
You can find a variety of items here, from clothing and furniture to home goods and antiques, all at bargain prices. I’ve discovered some great pieces and affordable home decor that has helped furnish our home.
Second-Hand Shopping at the Habitat for Humanity ReStores
Habitat for Humanity ReStores are a great place to find gently used furniture, appliances, and building materials. With locations throughout New Jersey, these stores offer affordable prices while supporting Habitat for Humanity’s mission to build homes for those in need.
Each purchase helps fund homebuilding projects, making your shopping experience both rewarding and impactful. It’s one of the reasons we love to shop there and you can really find cool items for your home. The quality is usually very good and there is a range of styles you’ll find.
I usually go second-handing shopping at the Manville and Dover locations and have found lots of vintage and affordable home decor at both.
The Independent Thrift, Madison, New Jersey
The Independent Thrift in Madison, NJ, offers a curated selection of vintage clothing, accessories, and unique home decor items. This shop is known for its friendly atmosphere and carefully selected merchandise, making it a favorite spot for locals and visitors alike looking for high-quality second-hand treasures.
Second-Hand Shopping at the Center Square Thrift Shop, Belmar, New Jersey
Located in the heart of Belmar, The Center Square Thrift Shop provides a diverse range of second-hand items, including clothing, books, and household goods. This community-focused shop offers great deals and supports local initiatives, making it a fantastic stop for thrifting enthusiasts.
Antiquing for Vintage Decor at The Dainty Dandelion in Chester, New Jersey
One of my favorite local antique stores to shop is super local to me right here on Main Street called the Dainty Dandelion. It’s my favorite local shop.
And the best part? My friend Monica owns it and she finds the coolest stuff! Plus she refinishes some of her finds and sells all American handmade items. Monica finds the coolest vintage pieces and lots of architectural salvage. Oftentimes, I drive by just to see what she has stocked outside.
She sometimes keeps pieces as they are and sometimes she refinishes them. I’ve bought a few doors and shutters from her already. They look great in a corner with some plants and other accessories.
Monica also supports local makers and everything made is from the USA. Like this rustic A-frame birdhouse with the corrugated roof. Originally I picked it up to use outside, but I love it more inside.
It’s tucked in on top of the cabinet among my vintage crocks, vases, and faux greens. I’ve never seen a birdhouse that is in the shape of an A-frame before. Have you?
But I also enjoy picking through some of the architectural salvage pieces she finds. I recently snagged this chippy black shutter that I absolutely love! It looks great against the shiplap in my laundry room with some pretty spring florals.
My Favorite Second-Hand Shopping Adventure in New Jersey
One of my most memorable thrifting adventures happened at the Habitat for Humanity ReStore in New Jersey. Chris and I were on the hunt for unique pieces, and we stumbled upon a super cool cabinet with intricate details that caught my eye immediately.
As I admired it, I noticed someone else lingering around, seemingly interested but eventually walking away. Determined not to lose it, I stayed close, whispering loudly and frantically texting Chris to come find me.
Of course he was nowhere in sight, and I couldn’t leave the piece unattended. Eventually, he showed up, and we successfully secured the cabinet. It now sits proudly in our home, a constant reminder of that thrilling day at the ReStore.
Thrift Shopping in Vermont: Unearthing Historic Treasures
Exploring thrift stores in Vermont is like stepping into a treasure trove of history. The rich cultural heritage of New England is reflected in the abundance of unique and one-of-a-kind items you’ll find. From vintage furniture to historic collectibles, Vermont offers a thrifting experience unlike any other.
I love shopping in all the local thrift and antique stores there and am always find something cool to bring home. The pickings here are often more plentiful compared to New Jersey, with a higher chance of discovering rare and valuable pieces that tell a story.
The town where our cabin is even has a weekly outdoor antique market in spring through fall. We found some cool stuff there! I wish we had more of that in NJ but we just don’t. Having a home in both states, I think it’s much easier to find things in VT than here in NJ.
Whether you’re looking for rustic farm-style decor, antique household items, or handmade crafts, Vermont’s thrift shops have lots of incredible things to offer.
Let’s dive into some of the best thrift stores in the area where you can start your treasure hunt.
Second Hand-Shopping at Twice Blessed in Dover, Vermont
Twice Blessed, located at 45 VT-100 in West Dover, is a massive thrift store that offers a wide variety of items, including furniture, clothing, sporting goods, and home decor. This community-focused store supports local families and individuals, providing them with essential items and resources. It’s a treasure trove where you can spend hours finding hidden gems at unbeatable prices.
Shopping the Outdoor Antique and Flea Market, Wilmington, Vermont
Running from May through October, the outdoor antique and flea market in Wilmington is a must-visit for any thrifting enthusiast. This market features numerous vendors selling a range of items, from antiques and collectibles to handmade crafts and vintage goods. The open-air setting and seasonal operation make it a unique thrifting experience, perfect for finding one-of-a-kind treasures while enjoying the beautiful Vermont weather.
Chapman’s Antiques, Wilmington, Vermont
Chapman’s Antiques in Wilmington offers a delightful mix of antique furniture, vintage collectibles, and unique home decor items. Known for its extensive and well-curated selection, this shop is a favorite among locals and visitors seeking high-quality antiques. Each piece has its own story, making every visit an exciting journey through history.
Thrift Store Shopping at the Second Hand Rose in Bennington, Vermont
Second Hand Rose in Bennington is a charming thrift store that features a wide range of second-hand items, including clothing, furniture, and household goods. The store is well-organized, making it easy to browse through the various sections. Whether you’re looking for a new outfit or a unique piece of furniture, Second Hand Rose offers plenty of options at affordable prices.
My Favorite Thrifting Adventure in Vermont
One of my favorite thrifting adventures took place at the outdoor antique and flea market in Wilmington, Vermont. It was a perfect day to explore with my family, and the market was brimming with vintage finds that were perfect for my home and garden. We found everything from rustic garden decor to unique household items.
As the day wore on and we were about to leave, I spotted a charming wine cabinet that would look fantastic in my foyer. However, the price was a bit steep, and we decided to think it over. Just as we were heading back to the car, I couldn’t shake the image of that wine cabinet.
I sent my daughter Tori back to the vendor to negotiate a deal. She managed to get a great price, and we drove home with the wine cabinet securely in the trunk. Now, every time I look at it, I’m reminded of that wonderful family day spent thrifting in Vermont.
Thrifting Tips and Tricks
Thrifting is more than just shopping; it’s an adventure filled with the excitement of uncovering hidden gems. Whether you’re a seasoned thrifter or new to the game, having a few strategies can make your thrifting trips more successful and enjoyable.
Here are some expert tips to help you spot valuable items, negotiate better prices, and choose the best times to visit your local thrift stores. These insights will enhance your thrifting experience and help you find those unique pieces that make second-hand shopping so rewarding.
Spotting Valuable Items
When thrifting, keep an eye out for quality materials and well-known brand names. Items with unique designs or that feel sturdy and well-made are often worth picking up. For example, vintage clothing made of natural fibers like wool, cotton, or silk usually signifies durability and timeless style.
Negotiation Strategies
Don’t be shy about negotiating prices. Most thrift stores are open to a bit of haggling, especially for items that have been on the shelf for a while. A friendly smile and a polite request can often lead to great deals. Start by offering a reasonable lower price and be prepared to meet halfway.
Best Times to Visit
Timing is everything in thrifting. Early mornings and weekdays typically offer the best selection since stores are freshly stocked and less crowded. Weekends can be busier, but they also often have sales. To snag the best finds, visit regularly and get to know the store’s restocking schedule.
Final Thoughts on Thrifting in New Jersey vs. Vermont
Thrifting in New Jersey and Vermont offers unique experiences, each with its own charm. In Vermont, the abundance of historic pieces and one-of-a-kind items makes it a thrifter’s paradise, with treasures waiting at every turn. The rich cultural heritage of New England adds a special touch to each find. It’s one of the reasons I love to go every time we visit the cabin.
While New Jersey might have fewer opportunities compared to Vermont, the Garden State still boasts amazing finds. The thrill of discovering hidden gems at places like the Habitat for Humanity ReStore or Market Street Mission Thrift Store makes the hunt worthwhile.
Each thrift store has its own character, offering a diverse range of items that can transform your home and garden on a budget. No matter where you are, the joy of thrifting is universal, and there’s always something cool waiting to be found. Happy thrifting!
Share Your Second-Hand Shopping Finds With Me!
One of the best parts of thrifting is sharing the excitement of your finds with others who appreciate the thrill of the hunt. I love hearing about the unique items my readers discover on their thrifting adventures.
Have you found a vintage piece that perfectly completes your home decor? Or perhaps you’ve stumbled upon a rare collectible that you couldn’t believe was tucked away in a thrift store? Share your stories and photos with me in the comments below! Let’s celebrate the joys of second-hand shopping together.
Thanks for stopping by the blog today!
Enjoy your day! xoxo
Thrifting with the Gals: Second-Hand Shopping Trips From Around the USA
I went thrifting with some friends from all over the country. Well, we didn’t actually thrift together, but we shopped at some local thrift and antique stores then joined up on our blogs to show you the things we found where we live.
(click on the blog name to read the post)
Rachel from The Ponds Farmhouse
Kristin from White Arrows Home
Ann from Dabbling and Decorating
