Home » Garden » How to Make the Best Compost Recipe

How to Make the Best Compost Recipe

Looking for ways to improve your garden soil and feed plants naturally? Follow these tips to learn how to make the best compost recipe.

In this post, I’m going to show you how to make compost.

It’s pretty simple to do and is one of the best ways to improve your soil as well as keep plants healthy.

Here’s everything you need to know about composting. Plus learn how to make the best compost recipe for your garden.

(Posts on stacyling.com may contain affiliate links. Click HERE for full disclosure.)

The Most Asked Question I Get is…What do you feed your plants with?

And while I do use some fertilizers for my roses, annuals, and houseplants, compost is a source of nutrition for all of my plants, perennials, shrubs, and trees.

In spring and fall, I add a layer of compost to my existing gardens and container plantings.

People are generally surprised that I don’t fertilize my perennials, shrubs, and trees with more, but the truth is, they don’t need fertilizers if they are fed with good soil.

And one of the best ways to have good soil is to make a compost recipe or buy it from the garden nursery.

cut flower garden in nj in late summer

What is Compost Used For?

There are several benefits to using compost in gardens.

  • Compost helps build good soil structure.
  • It feeds earthworms and other microbes in the soil.
  • Compost helps maintain a neutral soil Ph level.
  • It helps retain moisture and air.
  • Adds nutrients to keep plants healthy and better protected from pests and disease.
garden nj shade garden

What is Usually in Compost?

Compost is made of organic decomposed matter that includes:

  • leaves, twigs, grass, and other garden debris
  • kitchen waste from plant-based scraps
  • cardboard and other paper products like newspaper or plain paper plates. Be sure there’s no plastic coverings on anything.

Compost is made when organic material like food scraps decompose over time.

The decomposition becomes what we gardeners call “gold” because it is high in nutrients that enrich overall soil quality and promotes happy, healthy plants.

NOTE: Leaf mold is a little different from compost. To learn more about leaf mold and how to make it, CLICK HERE.

Fall Clean-Up

Does Compost Turn Into Soil?

Since compost is made of organic material and soil includes other elements such as minerals and rocks, when mixed together, the result is amazing for plants.

Thus, compost is considered to be a soil amendment that mixes with existing garden soil to improve its overall structure and health.

The Best Compost Recipe

What Should NOT Go in a Compost Recipe?

Before tossing things into the compost pile, be sure to exclude the following:

  • Fish
  • Meat scraps
  • Dairy, fats, and oils
  • Anything related to the black walnut tree – it’s toxic and prevents certain plants from growing.
  • Plants that suffered from pest or disease problems.
  • Weeds with seeds. I generally don’t compost them at all to avoid this problem.
  • Coal and Charcoal Ashes. Some ash from wood burning fireplace is OK but use very little.
  • Cat/Dog animal waste
  • Plants or wood waste that was treated with pesticides
Dahlia 'Penhill Watermelon'
Tour my gardening zone 6a cottage gardens

How to Make the Best Compost Recipe

Composting is a natural process of breaking down organic matter into nutrient-rich soil. Here’s a recipe for making the best compost.

Supplies Needed to Make the Best Compost Recipe

It’s super simple to start composting. I used to have piles of compost but then I was gifted one like THIS several years ago.

And until moving, this is what I’ve been using to make compost.

It’s a little smaller than what I had, but the animals can’t get to it and it breaks things down a little quicker.

Here’s what you need:

  • Compost bin (make or buy)
  • Kitchen scraps (see above)
  • Yard or garden waste (see above)
  • Garden fork
Bearded Iris and Allium in the Cottage Garden

Directions to Make the Best Compost Recipe

When making compost, it’s very similar to baking a cake, except you are doing it in pile outside. Whether you compost kitchen scraps or garden wastes, there are a few basic steps to follow.

What you include and how you do it are very important. So make sure you don’t incorporate anything from the what NOT to use list above.

  • Find a sunny spot in the yard to place the compost bin.
  • Choose a compost bin. You can make or buy one.
  • Place kitchen and yard waste into the bin.
  • Add or spread existing soil or compost over the compost pile.
  • Water the pile. To break down easier, materials should be damp to the touch.
  • Allow the pile to bake.
  • Mix the compost pile every few days or week with a garden fork to speed up the decomposition process. With my compost bin, I just need to flip it.
  • As the pile decomposes, it should appear dark and crumbly with bits of organic matter.

Gardening Tip – to speed up the process even more, chop or shred organic materials before adding them to the compost pile.

how to make the best compost recipe
How to make the best compost recipe
How to Make the Best Compost Recipe

Don’t Want to Make a Compost Bin? Shop Here

No matter what size home or property you have, there are compost bins readily available to fit your needs.

More About Composting

Do you make your own compost for the garden? I would love to know more in the comments below.

And don’t miss joining my Gardening DIY and Decorating Community on Facebook for more chatter. And follow along there and on Instagram as well. There are behind-the-scenes daily things that I share on Instagram that don’t make it on the blog. Would love to see you there too!

If you prefer to binge-watch Bricks ’n Blooms on TV, we go more in-depth with tours and posts on my YouTube channel. Would love to hang out with you there!

Sign Me Up!

Sign up for my free newsletter to get blog posts, seasonal tips, recipes, and more delivered straight to your inbox!

Plus, get free VIP access to my Resource Library where you’ll find insider freebies not readily available to the public.

Pin and Save It For Later

Zen garden koi pond in full bloom with japanese snowbell tree, rhododendron, mountain laurel and elderberry with staddle stone and koi fish

Bricks ‘n Blooms Weekly 134

Hi there! I hope you had a great week! Random Things Happening Behind the Scenes at Bricks ‘n Blooms What a week it was! After a long weekend in Vermont, I got busy again in the gardens doing some weeding, maintenance and pruning. The lonicera on the arbor in the potager garden was getting a…
Read More Bricks ‘n Blooms Weekly 134
view of our 1850 farmhouse with front porch and beautiful flower gardens from the pool garden with green fence - has roses, bearded iris, buckeye tree, viburnum, and baptisia

Bricks ‘n Blooms Weekly 133

Hi there! I hope you had a great week! And Happy Memorial Day Weekend! Random Things Happening Behind the Scenes at Bricks ‘n Blooms What a week it was! I FINALLY wrapped up all of my seeds starting for the spring. Over the last week, I planted several pumpkin seeds, sunflowers, and more cosmos. So…
Read More Bricks ‘n Blooms Weekly 133

Thank you so much for following along.

Enjoy a beautiful day! xo

Stacy Ling

Let’s Connect!

If you like this post, please follow me @bricksnblooms on Pinterest, Facebook, Instagram, and Tik Tok. Subscribe to my YouTube Channel. Or join my Facebook Group.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


  1. Stacy, I’ve been composting for years and it’s such a great way to reduce up to 30% of your waste. And the condition of the compost soil is almost magical. Hard to believe all those scraps and dry material can create something so enriched. Thanks for sharing. Composting is truly one of the easiest gardening things to do.

    1. It is so easy and SO good for the gardens! Not to mention, you can get rid of scraps and stuff with much less waste! At our next house, I’m hoping to maintain a much larger pile than I have now.

  2. Pingback: Dirt Road Adventures - Get Ready for The Holidays - The Ponds Farmhouse